Uber Australia settles a long-running legal battle over drivers’ employment status

Uber Eats Driver | iTMunch

Uber Australia settled a Federal Court case with an ex-Uber Eats driver and her husband, outside court. Amita Gupta, an Adelaide-based former Uber Eats driver and Santosh (Amita’s husband) completed over 2000 deliveries between September 2017 & January 2019. Ms Gupta claims that she was dismissed unfairly for being late with one of her deliveries.

Ms Gupta’s claim was rejected by the Fair Work Commission saying that she was not an ’employee’ by law and hence, did not have jurisdiction to hear her case. 

Ex-Uber Eats driver & the Transport Workers’ Union

Ms Gupta and her husband reached out to the Transport Workers’ Union who took up their legal fight to the Federal Court, which heard the entire detailed submissions last month in December.  A panel of judges at the Federal Court questioned arguments from lawyer for Uber Ian Neil SC during the hearing, that there was ‘no relationship of employment’ between Ms Gupta Uber. Mr Ian added that the court didn’t need to make any “positive finding as to what that relationship is or was”.

“This is not a debating club; we don’t just have a theoretical construct to ask ourselves about.”, says the Uber lawyer. Mr Neil SC said that there is a “quadrilateral relationship” between 4 parties: Uber Eats, the restaurant, the delivery driver and the customer. He added the drivers worked for themselves and they were the “delivery partners”, and not employees and were under no obligation to accept delivery jobs or complete deliveries. 

Uber Australia’s submission was that there was no such requirement, and Mr Neil told the court that if the applicant chose to accept a delivery and made a positive choice to accept the delivery, she was free to abandon it at any time.

SEE ALSO: Should Google and Facebook pay for news in Australia?

Transport Workers’ Union’s statement

the TWU said in a statement that Ms Gupta was sued after she was 10 minutes late with a food delivery and that Uber, the parent company of Uber Eats, had tried to deny any link to its workers. 

TWU said that a settlement was the only option left to the tech giant in the face of a potential judgement that could have utterly altered how Uber and other gig economy companies operate in Australia,” said National Secretary Michael Kaine. 

Questions of the judges to Uber exposed just how utterly farcical and ridiculous it’s contract contortions are, when it comes to getting around the country’s labour laws, he said. “Uber has constructed and works on such a business model that refuses its workers any rights to minimum pay, to challenge an unfair sacking or to protective gear or proper training, he adds.

SEE ALSO: The ACCC rejects Google’s assurance over Fitbit data usage

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Previous articleKPMG Australia appoints 8 new Management Consulting Partners
Next articleCES 2021: Dates, ticket prices, featured speaker & more details
Riddhi Jain is a technology content writer. She is based in India and has been working as a content writer since 2018. Riddhi has been writing content in the tech domain since May 2020 and can’t get enough of it. Riddhi has pursued most of her education from her hometown, Indore. She has graduated as a Bachelor of Business Administration and discovered her love for writing blogs while pursuing an internship during college. Once she discovered her love for writing, she went on to improve this skill set (and hasn’t stopped since). Riddhi’s writing relationship with iTMunch began in May 2020. This is where she developed a knack for writing content for the technology domain. She's an expert in tech content writing who has written over 700 blogs for iTMunch in just a year. Riddhi loves diving deep into tech sub-domains like financial technology, marketing technology, HR technology, Artificial Intelligence and gaming technology. She loves staying updated with the latest and upcoming trends in digital marketing, digital payments, fintech, gaming, web design and app development. She cherishes writing about futuristic technologies like blockchain and cryptocurrency, NFTs, Internet of Things, Facial Recognition, Machine Learning, Edge Computing, etc. Riddhi also likes to keep an eye on what’s going on with the tech titans like Google, Facebook and Apple. One of her major interests is in staying updated with the latest IT startups and the groundbreaking technologies they’re coming up with. When Riddhi is not writing content, she is binging on documentaries on Netflix (check out ‘The Great Hack’, ‘Seaspiracy’, and ‘What the Health’). She also likes reading books once in a while (Yuval Noah Harari and Michelle Magorian are some of her favorite authors). Riddhi also likes listening to podcasts like The Tim Ferriss Show (do listen to the ones with guest Naval Ravikant) and The Joe Rogan Experience.